Pro Version | USD Change Currency | Help | Mobile Site

Q&A: Kristy Melton, Clos Du Val, Napa Valley

Q&A: Kristy Melton, Clos Du Val, Napa Valley
© Traci Seville
Kristy Melton wasn’t born when Napa's Clos Du Val took part in the 1976 Judgment of Paris. But at the age of 31, she now makes Clos du Val’s small-batch and premium wines.

Where did you grow up?

I grew up in a small rural area outside of El Paso, Texas, which is the desert in the southwest of the country.

It’s not an area renowned for wine.

You know, the first vines in America were planted along the river in El Paso by the Spanish missionaries that came through in the 1500's.

Are there any vines left?

There are a few. There’s a small resurgence. There are a couple of wineries near my parent’s home, but there weren’t any when I grew up there.

Who or what inspired you to enter the wine industry?

I was doing medical research at the National Institute of Health in Washington D.C. and I really thought that’s what I wanted to do for the rest of my life. But it left me feeling unfulfilled. I’m a really tangible person and at the end of the day, a piece of paper with data on it wasn’t doing it for me. I wanted to produce something that I was really proud of.

Do you make wine for the critics, the consumers or yourself?

My philosophy is, I make wine for the sake of the wine. Ultimately, the grape and the site dictate the initial course of that wine, and even though I have overall preferences in terms of style and interpretation, I’m not going to make a cabernet sauvignon from mountain fruit as I would from valley fruit. It’s about respecting the wine and doing what’s right. If the critics happen to like that wine, that’s wonderful, but if they don’t, it’s not what I set out do in the first place.

Wine scores are important to Napa producers. What’s your opinion of ranking wines?

I find it really interesting to give wines a score and call something a perfect – or 100-point –  wine, because there was no concept of having a perfect wine until we had numerical scores. In my life, I have a perfect albarino on the beach with oysters or a glass of cabernet when I’m catching up with a friend. But perfection is contextual and subjective. So while it feels great to get a really good score, it’s impossible for those scores to be objective. We don’t give scores to Shakespeare or Picasso, because it’s difficult to put parameters on greatness. We can probably all agree on parameters for flaws, but greatness? Never.

Vines in one of Clos du Val's Carneros vineyards
© Clos du Val/Marvin Collins | Vines in one of Clos du Val's Carneros vineyards

Do you think there is such a thing as luxury wine?

It depends on the person. Personally, I can’t afford many of the luxury wines and more power to the people that can. There are really good, really drinkable wines and then there are wines that are pretty exclusive, made by hand, and so these wines do cost more. The price-to-quality ratio is important to consumers. If we are going to charge a premium for a wine, we want it to the best product we can make, with a lot of care and attention.

In wine terms, who are your heroes?

I like to think outside the box and the pioneer women of Napa fascinate me, particularly those who made wine. They were here in the late 1800's and were beginning to start farming and growing grapes. When I’ve had a hard day I think what it must have been like for them, plowing fields with horses, not having pumps or refrigeration. Everything seems so much easier today. I think they are the real heroes that made a name for Napa wine a century ago.

What has been your greatest winemaking achievement?

While making an amazing wine feels really good, I actually get more pleasure from troubleshooting or fixing a really challenging issue. Harvest 2011 threw everything at us that nature could think of. If you didn’t make the right decisions or take the right steps at the right time you got some pretty unusual stuff. I found that really thinking about what we were doing made wines that were good, and way better than expected. To me, it is really rewarding to come out ahead when something is so challenging and difficult.

Whom or what do you pray to during vintage?

There are three very important things. Firstly, the ‘Please don’t let it rain' god. Second, the ladies who make the breakfast burritos at Soda Canyon deli, and third, the Colombian coffee growers. Because without those three, our world would not go round at harvest.

There’s a noticeable disparity between the numbers of male and female winemakers. Why do you think this is so?

First of all, winemaking is a physically challenging job. You get really dirty and really sticky some days and so that’s not always appealing to some women. It’s also a multidisciplinary field. It’s not just taking grapes and making them into wine; you have to understand plants, the weeds, microbiology, organic chemistry, and on top of that, it’s mechanics. Throw on public speaking and customers relations and it’s a really multifaceted career. It can be overwhelming for some women. But things are changing.

Harvest time at Clos du Val
© Clos du Val/Marvin Collins/Andy Berry | Harvest time at Clos du Val

What do you drink on a "school night"?

Our cuisine tends to be a bit lighter in California, so I like to have a wine that goes with that –  [such as] an aromatic white or a pinot noir.

What do you see when you look in the mirror?

I see a very hardworking person who has also been very fortunate in life. I had some tough things to deal with early on, but hard work, support from family and friends, and a little good luck along the way has got me where I am today. I couldn’t be happier.

Where would you like to be buried?

My thought on that is I’ll be dead, so I doubt I’ll mind where they bury me.

What would you want your last wine to be?

An old vintage Sauternes, because it makes me smile every time.

What brings you the greatest happiness?

Something as simple as sharing a nice bottle of wine [and] some bread and cheese with friends, and having a lot of laughs on a sunny day.

What do you think would make the world a better place?

Tolerance for everyone else, because most problems and conflicts are based on intolerances of other people’s views and actions.

In the end, what really matters?

Finding what you love to do, surrounding yourself with people that add to your happiness, and doing something good for someone else.

Signup for our Free Weekly Newsletter

Write Comment

  • Comments

    Jose Oliveira wrote:
    06-Jul-2012 at 10:36:27 (GMT)

    Hi Kristy, I loved this interview. When we recently met in Portugal I did not have much of a chance to chat with you but here I have the opportunity to know a little more about your personality. I particularly like the intelligent answer to Rebecca's question about wine scores. Well done! take care!

Recent Stories

Q&A: Elena Pantaleoni, the Leading Lady of "Natural Resistance"

The owner of La Stoppa winery is a respected leader in Italy’s natural wine movement. She features in “Mondovino” filmmaker Jonathan Nossiter’s new documentary, “Natural Resistance.”

Meet Tokaj Disznóko's László Mészarós

The managing director of Tokaj’s Disznókő estate, talks about changes in the wind for Hungary's famous sweet wines.

Sexual Fantasies in the ABC Cellar with Jim Clendenen

Jim Clendenen, the owner of Au Bon Climat (ABC) has been called “the most iconic American wine personality since Robert Mondavi." He tells Katherine Cole that his honesty and lack of "self-filter" gets him in trouble.

The Oz Clarke Interview

From Shakespearean actor to one the world’s best-loved wine personalities.

Alfred Tesseron: The Progressive Leader of Pontet-Canet

In his 20 years at the helm of Pauillac estate Château Pontet-Canet, Tesseron has introduced unconventional methods including green harvesting, biodynamics and now amphora. He reveals the ups and downs of his career.

Alexandra Marnier Lapostolle: From Grand Marnier to Grand Designs in Chile

The Grand Marnier heiress behind Chile's first-ever Wine Spectator Wine of the Year.

The Mugnier Interview: The Master of Musigny

What keeps Burgundy's Frédéric Mugnier awake at night?

The Next Generation at Domaine Chevrot

Pablo Chevrot returned to the Côte de Beaune village where he grew up to take over the reins at the family domaine in 2002. He has since converted to organics but it's not been easy, he explains.

The Interview: Life is a Cabaret For Jean-Charles Boisset

From French Rabbit Tetrapaks to grands crus Burgundy, the Boisset empire marches on, with a self-confessed dreamer at the helm.

Q&A: Moët & Chandon's Benoît Gouez

Why one of Champagne's leading producers has taken a step away from a "house style" for its vintage wines.

The DRC Interview: Aubert de Villaine

"Burgundy has always been, and will always be, a liability because it is not easy to understand."

Being Burgundian With Bruno Clair

Domaine Bruno Clair was born out of the old Clair-Daü estate, which was dismantled in the mid-1980s after difficulties over inheritance. Clair stepped into the breach.

The Force Behind Deutz Champagne

Fabrice Rosset is the heavy who rescued Champagne Deutz, built Louis Roederer’s import arm, and jazzed up the Rhône’s Delas Frêres brand. He opens up to Katherine Cole.

Hugh Johnson on His Life in Wine

After a long career in traditional publishing, the best-selling writer is now a Twitter devotee.

The Wacky World of Sean Thackrey

Meet a winemaker who prefers ancient manuscripts over modern textbooks for winemaking advice.

Site Map About Contact Business Advertising Social