Pro Version | USD Change Currency | Help | Mobile Site

California Chardonnay: From Butterball to Balance

California Chardonnay: From Butterball to Balance
© Wikimedia
A new wave of Californian chardonnay producers are seeking more restraint, but is that what consumers want?

At long last California chardonnay appears to be shedding its reputation among serious wine drinkers as a plump butterball best paired with popcorn. While fat, oaky chardonnays from mass-market producers continue to find a ready audience, a new trend toward leaner, more focused expressions of the wine grape is gaining attention as well.

At a recent seminar, San Francisco Chronicle wine editor Jon Bonné said there had been a distinct movement away from chardonnay styles laden with residual sugar and vanilla creaminess. “None of the seminar panelists’ winemaking is going to walk down that Rombauer road,” he joked.

For those not familiar with Rombauer Winery's Napa Chardonnay, it has become shorthand for the buttery style that sparked the “Anything But Chardonnay” backlash in the 1990's. The Rombauer reaction also prompted a move towards unoaked, fruit-filled, white-wine varieties such as sauvignon blanc, pinot grigio and moscato, which continue to appeal to consumers.

Perhaps surprisingly, the anti-chardonnay rebellion has not seen the grape's acreage dwindle. There are more chardonnay vines in the ground in the United States than all red-wine vines put together, according to the New York Times. California chardonnay – now planted on nearly 100,000 acres of vineyard land – accounts for more than 53 million cases of wine shipped to U.S. consumers each year, according to the latest figures (2009) available from the state's Wine Institute. That's a rise of more than 10 million cases in just six years. In any year, chardonnay sales top those of the variety's two closest competitors, cabernet sauvignon and Champagne, combined.

Not bad for a grape that nobody paid any attention to until 1976, when the 1973 Chateau Montelena Chardonnay took first place in a blind tasting of American and French wines at the legendary Judgment of Paris. Overnight it became a world-famous celebrity wine grape. Wineries tore out acres of chenin blanc, colombard and other white varieties to replant with the Wente-clone of chardonnay.

Winemakers at first tried to emulate the leaner French Burgundies, but in time developed a much lusher, riper version that traded nuance for instant gratification. They produced a beach-buddy Californian wine in spirit as well as substance. Within their bottles, the sun never set.

“Until recently, chardonnay in this state was all made in one style, the California style,” admits Raj Parr, co-founder of Sandhi Winery in Santa Barbara. “The style was to create a blowsy cocktail wine.”

But no more. Now, chardonnays across the state are delivering a clear and unmistakable expression of place.

The Chanin Wine Company grows chardonnay grapes at Santa Barbara's Los Alamos vineyard
© Chanin Wine Company | The Chanin Wine Company grows chardonnay grapes at Santa Barbara's Los Alamos vineyard

Winemaker Gavin Chanin, from Chanin Wine Company in Santa Maria on the Central Coast, calls chardonnay the ultimate terroir grape. “It shows the site’s personality really well.”

Indeed, few grapes lend themselves to expressing their site. This non-aromatic variety also provides a relatively neutral canvas for winemakers to stamp their signatures. Chardonnay comes in a wide range of styles, from the green-tinged, racy wines of Chablis to the rich, powerful grands crus of Corton and Chassagne. There are fruit-filled oaky Australian chardonnays and the new wave of lean, unoaked, non malo-ed examples emerging from the Yarra Valley. Even California's straw-colored, mineral chardonnays display a radically different approach to the variety, accentuating its chameleon character.

In contrast to the old-school butterballs, Sandhi's chardonnay, from the maritime-influenced Santa Rita Hills, aims to capture the wet-stone earthiness of its gravel-based vineyard source. “We add nothing,” Parr says. “We let the grape speak for itself, with only a touch of new oak.”

It’s an oft-heard expression from winemakers. However, Parr and Chanin represent the new wave of premium California chardonnay producers attempting to convey a sense of place without a chunk of wood masking the fruit.

Their non-interventionist approach emphasizes purity, balance and structure. They prefer wild yeast fermentation in oak barrels and, in some instances, also stainless steel. There's no lees stirring, and they hold back on the new French oak.

To achieve a leaner style, producers are seeking out cooler sites and/or pick as much as a month earlier than those making fleshy, pineapple- and tropical-fruit-driven chardonnays that still dominate supermarket shelves.

For Matt Licklider, proprietor of producer LIOCO in West Sonoma, that ripe incarnation of chardonnay was the only choice available when he started to learn about wine. “At the time, chardonnay was like fat Elvis, and we wanted to bring svelte rockabilly Elvis back,” he says.

For adventurous winemakers across the state with similar ambitions, resurrecting a slimmed-down Elvis promises to be a continuing challenge. While there is a small but expanding and avid audience for site-specific California chardonnay hovering around $40 a bottle, the vast majority of consumers still prefer a more accessible, softer style at a lower price point.

L-R: Oak wood chips in chardonnay; stainless-steel aging barrels
© Wikimedia | L-R: Oak wood chips in chardonnay; stainless-steel aging barrels

That’s the view of retailers such as Mike Jordan, a buyer for K&L Wines in San Francisco. “You’re talking about only 5 percent or so of all chardonnay drinkers when you talk about preferring these minerally Burgundian wines. And many of those buyers are based right here in this city, where food is such a superstar," he explains.

"These chardonnays, like the superb ones from Steve Kistler [of Kistler Vineyards], are above all food wines," adds Jordan. "They have enough acid to pair beautifully. But most chardonnay buyers still want that creamy lushness and full body, even if not as over-oaked as in the past.”

With Parr and company standing at one extreme and Rombauer at the other, a number of seasoned chardonnay winemakers like Tor Kenward have taken a path down the middle. The owner and winemaker at his family winery in Napa Valley for two decades, Kenward picks his TOR chardonnay with sugar levels that translate to 14-plus percent alcohol.

He loves the honeysuckle in this grape as well as the raciness, along with the medium weight that distinguishes it from sauvignon blanc. He also admires the way it responds to handcrafting. ”Chardonnay takes on a personality more generously than other grapes. In that, it’s like riesling.”

Kenward is convinced that “you can’t make a Burgundian wine in California – the expression of fruit is too broad.” But you can dial back the toast, he says, and let the inviting essence of the grape’s character shine through without smothering it in oak. Kenward notes a change in that direction over the past decade. Well versed in the cycles of California chardonnay, he’s certain there are still more variations to come.

Related story:

Chardonnay, Moscato Get Social Media Buzzing

Signup for our Free Weekly Newsletter

Write Comment

  • Comments

    paul reece clarke wrote:
    10-Sep-2013 at 15:01:10 (GMT)

    Why dont you simply just buy Burgundy? Chablis, Maconaise,Chalonaise, Cote de Beaune. On the whole price wise vis a vis probably lower than your average US counterpart of the same quality versus cost. And definitely no concrete egg fermentation.....

  • Evan Teague wrote:
    23-Feb-2013 at 00:06:04 (GMT)

    For those interested in Burgundian style Chardonnays that express vineyard specific characteristics I highly recommend wines crafted by Ehren Jordan at Failla. Subtle oak to add structure but not so much such that the fruit is overpowered. Also incorporates concrete egg fermentation into the winemaking process. Great Burgundian style Pinot Noir as well.

Recent Stories

Numbers were down at Bordeaux's en primeur week

2013: Bordeaux's Divided Year

2013 was a vintage from hell for Bordeaux producers, but merchants are finding a bright side.

Bordeaux's Not So Greatest Hits

Jane Anson checks out some past Bordeaux vintages that make 2013 look positively stellar.

Oregon's Five Grand Cru Sites of the Future

With Burgundians arriving in their droves, Katherine Cole considers which Oregon vineyards have the potential to be the equivalent of a Burgundy grand cru.

Napa Caught Napping in American Appellation Race

How a small town in Missouri beat Napa to become the first American Viticultural Area.

Where Now For Crimean Wine?

The future of Crimea is uncertain and the local wine industry is wondering how the unrest will affect it.

Rapper Endorsement Puts Luc Belaire Rosé on Most-Wanted List

A French sparkler has emerged from the rear to grab a spot on Wine-Searcher's list of the 100 most-searched-for wines.

Chilean Immerses His Wines in Jazz

Can music change the taste of a wine? A recent experiment seems to suggest so.

Moving Military Technology to the Winery

Military technology isn't just about blowing the other guy to smithereens – it can also help you enjoy that glass of Pinot sooner than you thought.

How Long Before Napa Cabs Top $1000 A Bottle?

With 12 Napa wines selling for at least $1000 a bottle wholesale at Premiere Napa Valley, can the same price for regular releases be far behind?

British Government Stocks Some "Jolly Good" Wines

From $7 Chilean merlot to mature first growths, the British Government's cellar has a drop for all-comers.

Slow Cooking With Rollan de By's Jean Guyon

Melt-in-your-mouth beef cheek recipe

Burgundy's Spiraling Prices: Fact and Fiction

Burgundy vintners pray to St. Vincent for a bigger crop while consumers cross their palms with silver.

Berenice Lurton's Sweet and Salty Chicken

The head of Barsac's Château Climens shares her favorite recipe.

America vs. Europe: The Organic Divide

W. Blake Gray explores the debate over organic wine between the U.S. and the European Union.

Tim Adams' Lamb Shank Special

Slow-cooked lamb and a Clare Valley red is on the menu at Tim Adams' house.

Site Map About Contact Business Advertising Social