Pro Version | USD Change Currency | Help | Mobile Site
Advertisement

Wine Fraudster Kurniawan Should Be Released, Urge Lawyers

Ink stamps used to mark corks that were used as evidence in the trial of wine dealer Rudy Kurniawan
© AFP | Ink stamps used to mark corks that were used as evidence in the trial of wine dealer Rudy Kurniawan
Counterfeiter's defense argues for time served and claim he's too poor to pay fines. Finger pointed at collectors and auction houses for allowing fake wine culture.

Lawyers for convicted wine fraudster Rudy Kurniawan, who could be sentenced to 40 years in a U.S. prison, urged the federal judge to instead sentence their client to time served - 27 months. Kurniawan, 38, who has been unable to make bail all this time, has been in custody since his arrest on March 8, 2012.

The Indonesian-born Kurniawan, 38, who overstayed his U.S. visa, was convicted on fraud charges December for making and selling more than $1 million of fake fine wines that he had concocted in his Los Angeles kitchen.

He faces up to 40 years in prison when he is sentenced on May 29 on charges that include defrauding a financial institution to secure a $3 million loan.

His lawyer Jerry Mooney argues Kurniawan is too poor to pay more than a token fine of $12,500 and noted the federal government had already seized millions of dollars of his assets including the California home where his mother lives.

Mooney, using the prosecution’s figures, said Kurniawan spent more than $40 million on wine between 2004 and 2011.

He argued that the rarefied ranks of the rich who make up “The high end wine market... seems to recognize, even accept, that fraudulent wine is a part of its culture.”

Mooney argued Kurniawan, portrayed often as the youngest man in the room, learned from other collectors at tastings and auctions “that everybody expected there to be counterfeits. In fact, part of the contest was to see who could figure out what was real and what was fraudulent.”

Mooney suggested that if the fine-wine market were serious about combating fakes, it would insist on provenance in the same way as the fine art market does. That the auction houses have not done, that the collectors have not done so, means the market has chosen to accept fakes, he said.

“It is clear that there is no deterrence for the market and a greater prison sentence for Rudy beyond the time he has now served will not have any meaningful impact on those who engage in this trade,” he argued.

The prosecution is to submit their sentencing memorandum next week.

Related stories:

Kurniawan Faces Long Prison Sentence After Guilty Verdict

After Kurniawan's Conviction, What Now for Fine Wine?

Signup for our Free Weekly Newsletter


Write Comment


  • Comments

    M&D Wines wrote:
    07-May-2014 at 18:39:32 (GMT)

    I must add that I am in total agreement with David Boyer. RUDY KURNIAWAN is not a victim, and I feel no sympathy for this un-repentant man. Some very questionable choices were made by wine merchants and people dealing with him. If it seems too good to be true, it probably is. RGEYER@MNDFINEWINE.COM

  • David Boyer wrote:
    07-May-2014 at 14:29:52 (GMT)

    I almost feel sorry for Kuniawan, but only because of his representation. I'm not sure I've ever heard a weaker defense by his attorney fabricating a yarn that collectors accept counterfeit wine. Sure, collectors all aspire to pay handsomely for the privilege of owning a cellar full of fakes! Really, it's untenable and egregious to attempt shifting the blame of a counterfeit culture onto collectors. As for auction houses and merchants there can be little doubt than some are complicit and they should be rooted out and prosecuted. The fact that Kurnaiwan was convicted of making a little over $1 million in fake wines doesn't answer the question about where he got the other $40 million to spend on wine (and houses, watches, cars, and other luxury goods) between 2004 and 2011. I have a pretty good idea though. In this context, 40 years seems too little. David Boyer blog.classof1855.com








Recent Stories

The lots are lined up for viewing before the provincial auction

Sale of the Century Sees Petrus Go for $500

Napa's Quixote Winery Sold to Chinese Company

More Bordeaux Wineries Change Hands

Malibu the Latest Official U.S. Wine Region

Kurniawan Lawyers Dispute Victims' Claims

Burgundy Vineyards Experiment with Anti-Hail Nets

French Wine Exports to China Remain Strong but Slip Elsewhere

Prosecutors Name More Kurniawan Victims

Wine Writer Award Shortlist Revealed

Kurniawan Sentencing Drags on for Another Week

Sotheby's Targets Online Audience Through eBay

Noval Makes Late Declaration for 2012 Vintage

Insurance, Solidarity and Social Media for Hail Victims

Food and Wine MBA Scholarships Up for Grabs

Comparing the Great Growths of France


 
Site Map About Contact Business Advertising Social